[cabfpub] Revised Notice of Review Period - Ballot 198 - .Onion Revisions

[Gervase Markham]

On 16/05/17 21:39, Geoff Keating via Public wrote:
> The ‘ballot’ is the thing that includes the ‘redline or comparison’,
> bylaws section 2.3(a).  If it doesn’t have one of those, it’s not a
> ballot.  So the redline is definitely part of the ballot and if there’s
> some confusion it can be consulted to make it clear what change was
> voted on.
> 
> In addition, the redline has to be against a specific version of the
> guidelines.  If that wasn’t done properly, to the point where there’s a
> question as to what the ballot means or where votes might have been made
> based on the incorrect information, then I’d think the ballot would be
> invalid.

I think this is the best interpretationof the bylaws.

Gerv